Target folder permissions NOT inheriting with MOVED files

hi, has been exhausting researching , experimenting permission settings have files copied or moved "shared" folder inherit permissions of target parent folder. below environment in research.


mac pro [10.10.1 yosemite] shared folder. pc [non mac] mac clients using same workgroup name accessing shared folder. have used chmod acl settings below. permission inheritance works on newly created folders/files or copied [from locally or via networked computer] folders/files. but, inheritance not work on folders/files have been moved same mac or computer on same network. rather, these moved folders/files retain permissions of parent folder moved.


chmod -r +a "group:[examplegroup] allow list,add_file,search,add_subdirectory,delete_child,readattr,writeattr,readextat tr,writeextattr,readsecurity,file_inherit,directory_inherit" /path/to/folder


there times folders/files moved rather copied various users , want these files inherit permissions set on target shared folder. don't want manually configure read+write permissions , "apply enclose items" within info window.


strange behavior when comes file sharing read + write permissions assumed within group. have tested scenario on windows 8 , 10 pcs , shared folders there resulted in desired permission inheritance described above. microsoft doing apple not doing in case?


other things have tried:

-tinkertool system 2 application resulted in same undesired behavior.

-i have tested shared folder on usb connected flash drive represent external hard drive , permissions inherit desired. but, have external usb drive acting time machine backup. so, don't want connect 2 external drives in scenario.


possible solutions/workaround:

-i've heard desired permission inheritance might work on os x server version. have not confirmed work. have not tried this. don't want have upgrade or install server os on mac pro have permissions work. also, mac pro being used desktop 3rd party apps don't know restricted being used on os x server platform.

-nas dedicated file server might offer desired inheritable permissions. have not confirmed this. additional cost.


least costly , best solution have desired permissions inherited on mac pro. bought mac pro use day day work serve file server small office. there way desired inheritable permissions on moved folders/files? have done extensive googling , of workarounds have been using acl chmod commands, none of them addressed works on moved items. please help.

 

did not read first paragraph or two. normal new file move operating system gets permissions of folder goes existing file keeps existing settings. way *nix permissions work @ system level nothing going change that, cobble script , cron job execute change of permissions on folders in question keep them set way want.

 

Forums Macs macOS OS X Yosemite (10.10)

• iPhone
• Mac OS & System Software
• iPad
• Apple Watch
• Notebooks
• iTunes
• Apple ID
• iCloud
• Desktop Computers
• Apple Music
• Professional Applications
• iPod
• iWork
• Apple TV
• iLife
• Wireless